Menu of Mikie's Ice Cream & Green Cow in Greencastle, Pennsylvania, USA

Menu Overview

Mikie's Ice Cream & Green Cow, nestled at 179 S Antrim Way in Greencastle, PA, offers a nostalgic yet vibrant ice cream parlor experience that transcends the ordinary dessert stop. This establishment expertly blends classic Americana flavors with hearty comfort food, making it a beloved destination for families and locals alike.

The menu is a delightful mix of indulgent ice cream treats and satisfying savory dishes. Standouts like the Banana Split and Blueberry Cheesecake Ice Cream showcase their commitment to rich, creamy textures and balanced flavors. The Sundae Caramel with Nuts offers a perfect harmony of sweetness and crunch, while the Mint Moose Tracks balances refreshing mint and deep chocolate undertones, adding a sophisticated twist to familiar favorites.

Mikie’s serves its soft serve in classic cones priced reasonably at $2.69, with waffle cones slightly higher at $3.09, and their hand-dipped options starting at $3.39. One cannot overlook the delightful raspberry and chocolate soft serve served in homemade waffle cones—a true textural and flavor treat that leaves a lasting impression.

Beyond ice cream, the savory side of the menu surprises with unique offerings such as Cheesesteak Breaded Mushrooms and a hearty Cheesesteak Hoagie. These items bring inventive twists to Pennsylvania’s iconic sandwich, with the mushrooms praised for their crispy, satisfying bite. For those craving traditional comfort fare, the Hot Roast Beef & Fries and the Hot Turkey Sandwich with Mashed Potatoes deliver homestyle warmth and flavor in generous portions.

The mmm Pizza Burger offers a fusion of pizza-inspired zest layered on a classic burger, a creative highlight that complements Mikie’s diverse menu. Jason S., a regular, appreciates the variety, mentioning the savory brisket sandwich paired expertly with potato wedges, demonstrating Mikie's skill at balancing hearty and fresh elements.

Customer testimonials consistently reflect Mikie's welcoming atmosphere and family-friendly vibe. Corey Robertson shares how the shop has been a cherished part of his upbringing for over 20 years, highlighting the seamless continuity in service and atmosphere that appeals across generations. Jaime Brownell notes the spacious, comfortable dining environment and the addition of an arcade and gift shop, making Mikie's not just an ice cream stop but a full family outing.

The beverage selection matches the retro Americana feel, featuring sodas like Birch Beer and classic favorites such as Dr. Pepper, Root Beer, and Cherry Coke, ideal accompaniments to both sweet and savory dishes. The reasonable pricing and generous portion sizes emphasize value without sacrificing quality—an aspect Tina StClair explicitly praises with a 10/10 rating.

In essence, Mikie's Ice Cream & Green Cow embodies the charm of an old-fashioned ice cream shop enriched with modern culinary creativity. Whether you’re indulging in a creamy, hand-dipped scoop or savoring a well-crafted sandwich, the experience is both nostalgic and refreshingly vibrant. Busy yet inviting, Mikie's promises that each visit feels like coming home, with flavors that linger and memories to be made.